The organization Abriendo Jaulas Abriendo Mentes, led by activist Diana Valencia, has reported that the Environment Secretariat of Mexico City has distorted the ruling regarding the case of Ely, an African elephant whose well-being has been a source of controversy for years.
Since 2017, Diana Valencia has gathered evidence showing that Ely suffers from zoochosis, a psychological and behavioral disorder caused by conditions of captivity. Despite the evidence presented, the authorities in Mexico City have refused to allow international experts to assess whether transferring Ely to a sanctuary in Brazil is viable, even though that sanctuary has expressed its willingness to accommodate the elephant.
The Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation issued a ruling in favor of Ely, ordering various government entities to coordinate to ensure her overall well-being. However, the Environment Secretariat of Mexico City issued a statement distorting the meaning of the ruling, claiming that the elephant has not been subjected to animal abuse, which has been questioned by Ely's advocates.
The new ruling dictates a series of measures that authorities must comply with, including verifying Ely's living conditions, ensuring adequate nutrition with specialized advice, providing preventive care and treatment for possible illnesses, as well as being alert to abnormal behaviors that may indicate stress or emotional problems. Additionally, it leaves the possibility of relocation open if necessary for the elephant's well-being.
Despite the Court's ruling, the authorities involved in the case have shown resistance and opposed some of the mandated measures. The distortion of information by the authorities has been subject to criticism and questioning from civil society and animal rights advocates, who seek Ely's release to ensure her well-being and protection.
